Showing posts with label Adam and Eve. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adam and Eve. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Reponse to the Bill Nye and Ken Ham Creation-Evolution debate

I believe Mr. Ham's interpretation of Bible diverges sharply from the meaning of the text in Genesis. Is Ham's teaching really true to the Bible?

During the debate, Nye really pounded on the idea that Ham was not defending the Bible, but Ham's own interpretation of a Bible ("translated into American English"). Ham of course vehemently denied this. Ham believes that he is defending the true meaning of the Bible as the Word of God. In his certainty of this, it seems that Ham would not yield an inch. In this, I fault Ham in one particular belief he holds as dogma: the animal death was a result of man's sin. The Answers in Genesis site summarizes it. Before sin, everything was perfect, everything was vegetarian, death was punishment, and sin brought animal death. Ham's interpretation of Genesis is a wild stretch. He accused evolutionists of a bait in switch. Is Ham switching the real meaning of Genesis with man's errant interpretation?
Genesis explicitly states that death was a consequences only to man as a result of eating the tree.

But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die. Gen 2:17

Even when Eve distorts God's word to the serpent, she doesn't get that bit wrong:

"But God said, 'You shall not eat of the fruit of the tree that is in the midst of the garden, neither shall you touch it, lest you die.'"
"But the serpent said to the woman, "You will not surely die."

And finally when God metes out the curse:

"By the sweat of your face you shall eat bread, till you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken; for you are dust, and to dust you shall return." Gen 3:19 

Where in these words does Ham find it implied that all living creatures die as a result of the curse? He only comes to this conclusion by doing some logical gymnastics. He expresses that a "very good" creation would not include animal death. But his assertion is an insertion. It is unbiblical.

I admit, Ham's claim that animals used to be only vegetarian at least is more easily supported by the Bible in Genesis 1:30, which says, "To every beast of the earth and to every bird of the heavens and to everything that creeps on the earth, I have given every green plant for food." Yet the inconvenient fact remains: Animal death was never part of the curse.

Furthermore, I believe that an observation of biology and nature will reveal that—take Genesis as literally as you want—Genesis 1:30 does not say God has only given animals green plants as food. (And it may be well pointed out that there are many plants that are not green. If we take it in the most literal way, we may conclude that God never intended non-green plants to be eaten! Where would that leave non-plant organisms like mushrooms?)

God Created Animals to Hunt


During the debate, Nye fumbled a point about lions. He implied that if you look at a lion's teeth, you can see that it's a carnivore. Ham jumped on that, saying there are herbivores with sharp, pointed teeth using for tearing into fruit, for example. However, if you study the anatomy of a lion, you will see they are designed to be carnivores. Any reasonable person who studies feline biology will see that felines are built to be hunting machines. It's not a matter of switching out teeth, or switching out some bits of the digestive system as if you were converting a gas vehicle to diesel. Lions and house cats and cheetahs are perfectly built for the business of hunting prey. We love house cats because they are domesticated and safe, but anyone who observes how they play with their prey will see a very violent, vicious, and cruel aspect to cats. Nature red in tooth in claw!

During the debate, Ham presented one of his kinds as cat kind, or feline kind. (Ham teaches that God created animals to evolve after their "kind," in a very limited way, but never diverging so far from the original as Darwinist evolution suggests. Wolf-to-dog, but never reptile-to-bird.) I would argue that if you have a feline-kind animal that does not eat meat, it would not be feline in the first place.

Conclusion

Ham's assertion that all animals were created to be vegetarian is fundamental to the work of Answers in Genesis and the Creation Museum. I do not find that view to be biblical on one hand or scientifically sound on the other. 

Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version, copyright ©2001 by Crossway Bibles, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

God of the Predators

I have heard often repeated the idea that when Adam & Eve sinned, death entered into the world of animals and men.  Genesis 3:21, which records what happens after the sin, states, “And the LORD God made for Adam and for his wife garments of skins and clothed them.”  The argument then follows that when God did this thing, it was a shocking act: The first animal death, and as a direct consequence of sin.

First, I think this is due in part to a rather to the modern American’s imbalanced view on animal rights.  It is extremely unlikely that the ancient Jews would have seen anything shocking about this.  The Jews lived in a society that, for all its recorded history, depended on meat for sustenance.  A survey of the Scripture will reveal there is very little in it that has anything to do with our modern concept of animal rights.  It was taken for granted that animals would die, a little sympathy was reserved for God’s other creatures.  We, on the other hand, may go to length to have mercy on an intruding house spider, gingerly carrying it to the outside, after a hearty steak dinner.  We Americans can have several ongoing wars and scarcely be aware of it, and we eat meat everyday without giving a thought to the slaughterhouses.  I am no vegetarian.  I have confronted the tens of thousands of animals’ deaths to make my lifestyle possible, and I accept responsibility for it without guilt.

Second, I think we conceptualized God too much as a God of civilization.  Human beings are the only animals in all creation made in God’s image, and the only one with a capacity for rational thought.  (Someone would jump on me for calling humans animals!  But scientifically speaking, we very much are.)  Needless to say, we are held to a higher standard than the others creatures because among them, only we can form civilizations.  (Animals such as ants, bees, or terminates can have colonies, but they are not rationally governed.)  However, God is not only our God.  He is the Creator of the beasts and the God of the wild!

From childhood, I was taught that before the Fall of Man (that is, the sin of Adam & Eve) all animals lived in peaceful herbivorous coexistence.  Only after that did any animals develop a taste for meat.  It may seem well and good for a theologian nestled in the middle of human civilization to imagine the predatory animals are a cursed version of vegetarian creatures.  But a lion that didn’t hunt would not be built like a lion.  A spider that didn’t prey wouldn’t be built like a spider.  A predator species is designed to be a predator and nothing else.  Any serious study of zoology reveals beyond all doubt that predation is an essential trait of the animal world. 

Some Christian would no doubt react very strongly to this.  Saint Francis de Sales was overwhelmed with depression when he studied John Calvin’s teaching about predestination.  He couldn’t see how a God could be good and loving AND absolutely sovereign.  Or, to use another analogy, one child may have a mental crisis when they learn that their policeman father—who seemed to them so good and gentle—has killed men in the line of duty.  “Killing is bad!” the child murmurs in painful despair.  Another child has faith that their father is a good man, and so has faith that the father was right even when he took a man’s life.

God made animals to be wild.  He made them to hunt.  The natural world, without man’s intervention, can be an extremely cruel place.  How should we respond to this?  Should we accuse God of cruelty?  Should we melt in despair?  No, let us respond: “This is the LORD's doing; it is marvelous in our eyes” (Psalm 118:23).

And, if we accept this, a remarkable thing happens.  The gap closes between the seemingly inconsistent God of wrath in the Old Testament and the God of mercy of the New Testament (as some see it).  There are schools of theology that claim that our view of God as merciful and gracious shows that we have become more enlightened and more correct in our knowledge of Him.  Damned nonsense!  The dangerous side of God (which makes appearances in the New Testament as well—believe me!) seems consistent with the testimony of Creation itself and the predation God planned into the natural world.  Meanwhile, God’s mercy, His compassion, His love and grace (how these things elate my heart!) seem all the more the exception and all the more precious and amazing!  And meanwhile, the misconception of God as a gentle sissy are thrown right out the window.

“Behold therefore the goodness and severity of God.” Romans 11:22a (KJV).

Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version, copyright ©2001 by Crossway Bibles, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Photo credit: Nick Jewell.  "Breakfast for the Cub!" Click here to view the source.