Showing posts with label Peter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter. Show all posts

Sunday, October 23, 2011

What a strange way to be a rock!

"And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." Matthew 16:18

To Catholic readers, this verse seems to be the foundation of the papacy.  Jesus declares Peter, whose name means "stone," to be the rock upon which he we build the Church.  But for the rest of us--I don't how gently I can express it--we do not believe that God ever wanted there to be a pope, and we don't find Catholicism's evidence so compelling.  So, where does this verse leave us?

There's been plenty of controversy surrounding how to interpret it.  Is the rock Jesus is referring to Peter himself, or what Peter said, that Jesus is "the Messiah, the Son of the living God"? (Verse 16.)  I believe that in this case and many others as well, we would do well to humbly admit that the passage is ambiguous and that we might err in our best efforts to interpret it.  Nevertheless, I would like to offer my own theory about how it may be interpreted.

It is clear enough that more attention is given to Peter than any of the other apostles in Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.  Peter has been an example to generations of believers of faith and bravery as well as failure and cowardice.  Peter is honored by God to be chosen to be this example, and an even greater honor perhaps than being one of Jesus' inner circle of three disciples, which also included James & John.  More people can relate to Peter in his humanity than any other in the life of Christ.  But Peter vacillated.  One moment he stood tall, the next he jammed his sandal in his mouth.  Can such a man be called a rock?  Perhaps it was Jesus' foresight that led him to call Jesus a rock.  After Christ's resurrection and in the book of Acts, we see Peter really became a man of heroic faith and obedience.  But perhaps this also speaks of how God's grace wipes away every trace of sin to leave us pure and faultless before him.

Setting aside Peter's vacillation before Pentecost, we can read in Acts how God really did use him as a pillar in the new Church.  But we don't see him sitting at the tip-top of the church hierarchy.  For example, in Acts 15, James (one of the Jameses) holds the presiding role over the church council meeting.  What's more, in Acts' latter half, Peter is out-shined by none other than the outside Paul of Tarsus.  Paul becomes the focus of the book's second half.  If that is not enough, Paul write the majority of the books of the New Testament and teaches us the theology behind Christ's life and resurrection better than any other!  Peter does great works and builds the church in the beginning, but Paul becomes the supreme and authorize source of doctrine for every generation since, himself doing works that rivasl Peter's.

When John the Baptist saw the lime light was being transferred from himself to Christ, he assented, "He must increase, but I must decrease." In a way, that is what also happened the Peter.  He decreased while Paul increased.

I believe Peter was the rock on which the Lord built the church, but it wasn't a permanent or eternal rank for himself nor for successors.  It was a special albeit transient position for Peter.  He would do much to found the fledgling church only to pass it into other hands when his calling had ended.  But this is not to belittle the man, for Peter truly stands as a hero and a rock of the Christian faith.