I have trouble with abstinence-only education initiatives.
Jesus admitted there was at least one problem we as human beings will not be able to eliminate from our societies: poverty. “For you always have the poor with you,” He said, rebuking Judas (Mat 19:5). Just as poverty will always be a fallen humanity’s problem, it is self evident that sex outside of marriage will also be a problem. It is apparent from practically every time and culture in history. We cannot count on Christian charity to wipe out homelessness, and we cannot count on Christian influence to wipe out sexual immorality.
It was no easy matter to convince people that racism was wrong because racism is a disease that is rooted in one’s fundamental worldview. Those kinds of things take time to uproot. It would take much time to change people’s thinking before it is common to regard sex as a holy thing, as a responsibility and act of consummation.
We can see that sex outside of marriage is a problem for the church. How can we expect those outside the church to fare better than us? We, as Christians, must resist the sinful impulse to have sex outside of marriage, but it is absurd to expect society at large to succeed in this endeavor. It is made worse considering how society primes people to think casual sex is normal.
It is best, and the only sinless option to practice abstinence. But what is the cost when people inevitably disregard the righteous advice? If they know nothing about contraception, they will spread STDs, causing great suffering, saying nothing of the healthcare costs, and they will get pregnant. If we, pro-lifers as we are, get our way, they will have babies, and those children will be a tremendous and unplanned burden on their parents.
It takes less self control to use a condom than it does to say no to sex. They degree of self control is less because they are still giving into the stronger temptation, but at least they can avoid the physical consequences: life-threatening STDs and pregnancy. And by preventing unplanned pregnancies, we are reducing suffering for two people, not only one!
I think the only wise choice for us is to tell society to wait until marriage, but if you must, use a condom!
If we do this, we are also communicating something very valuable to them: it is your responsibility. Proving that it is all a matter of their responsibility is essential in the abortion debate. Pro-abortion women claim that we are depriving them of their choice of their bodies. We can counter saying that they were reckless in having sex without protection, and they used up their choice when they had unprotected sex. Because they have been irresponsible, they aren’t entitled to welfare when the child is born. (If the government chooses to grant welfare anyway, it is mercy, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing!) But if the woman wants to abort after consensual sex, it can only be interpreted as covering up for her own failure to use birth control.
(Women who are raped are a special case. They couldn’t be held responsible for their predicament, and they have my deepest sympathy. I only encourage them with all my heart to choose life.)
Romans 13:14 says, “But put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh, to gratify its desires.” Are we violating this verse and making provisions for the flesh by advocating contraception in this way? That passage is only speaking to those “inside the church,” that is, Christians. There is reason to interpret it this way, not only from the passage itself, but from the Epistle to the Corinthians (see 1 Cor 5:12-13).
Scripture quotations are from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version, copyright ©2001 by Crossway Bibles, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Scripture quotations are from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version, copyright ©2001 by Crossway Bibles, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.


No comments:
Post a Comment